Special Issue: Spatial Humanities and Contemporary Geographical Approaches (Accepted Manuscripts)
Special Issue: Spatial Humanities and Contemporary Geographical Approaches

Layering Public Park Histories: Uncovering the Effects of Restoration Idea[l]s in Post-War Urban Spaces in Germany and the U.S.

PDF
Laura Brannan Fretwell
George Mason University, USA
Eliane Schmid
Centre for Contemporary and Digital History (C2DH), University of Luxembourg, Luxembourg
Bio
“Hamburg. Zerstörungen des Luftkrieges bis Ende 1943” [“Hamburg. Air raid destructions until the end of 1943“], Konstanty Gutschow. Staatsarchiv Hamburg, 720-1/388-74_413.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48088/ejg.si.spat.hum.l.bra.30.44
Categories

Published 2024-11-22

Keywords

  • public parks,
  • Geographic Information Systems (GIS),
  • urban history,
  • spatial humanities,
  • post-World War II,
  • post-American Civil War
    • ...More
    Less

How to Cite

Fretwell, Laura Brannan, and Eliane Schmid. 2024. “S”. European Journal of Geography, November, s30-s44. https://doi.org/10.48088/ejg.si.spat.hum.l.bra.30.44.

Copyright (c) 2024 Laura Brannan Fretwell Fretwell, Eliane Schmid

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Received 2024-09-11
Accepted 2024-11-21
Published 2024-11-22

Abstract

This paper proposes a lens of analysis for studying how public urban park creation, often presented as inherently beneficial for the public by planners, government officials, and stakeholders, served to enforce prevailing social and political norms by excluding unwanted visitors and fostering specific codes of conduct. The two case studies of post-war park development in Richmond, Virginia, U.S., and Hamburg, DE, exemplify the social and political effects of restoration ideas and ideals on beneficiaries and non-beneficiaries. In Richmond, the construction of Chimborazo Park displaced and excluded an African American (Black) community during the aftermath of the Civil War, while Hamburg's Alsterpark was created within the city’s general post-World War II greening initiatives that included forced expropriation and behavior regulation. The joint spatial humanities based approach, which includes GIS modeling and archival source analysis, furthers historical investigation to more deeply understand patterns of displacement, exclusion, and social control. The paper offers an approach for critically examining the planning histories of parks that were created under the justification of restoration but operated as sites of contestation and ideology during moments of societal, political, and social reform.

Highlights:

  • Historical inquiry into the study of public urban park planning and development.
  • Use of GIS tools to analyze historical sources, especially atlases and maps, to reveal people’s perceptions, uses, and regulations of space as well as highlights experiences of place.
  • Challenges the assumption that parks are automatically beneficial to the public.
PDF

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.
Crossref
Scopus
Google Scholar
Europe PMC

References

  1. Amtsleiter. (1956). Amtsleiter, An die Baubehörde - V 5 - “Betr. Vorbereitung einer Senatsvorlage,” 31.05.1956. Staatsarchiv Hamburg, 327-1_151 Schaffung von Grünanlagen und Kinderspielplätzen, 1956-1969, Nr. 640.750 Beiakte 3.
  2. Anderson, B. (1991). Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism (Revised and extended edition). Verso.
  3. Baeumer. (1947). Entwurf von Baurat Baeumer an Senatsrat Dr. Elsner, 28.01.1947. Staatsarchiv Hamburg, 131-1 11_2708 Öffentliche Grünanla-gen - Erhaltung, Ausbau und Pflege [Band 1] [...] 1946-1963, Nr. 2708/5.
  4. Baeumer. (1951). Oberbaurat Baeumer an die Senatskanzlei -DI – Hamburg 1, Rathaus, "Unterhaltungskosten für öffentliche Parkanlagen", 17.01.1951. Staatsarchiv Hamburg, 131-1 11_2708 Öffentliche Grünanlagen - Erhaltung, Ausbau und Pflege [Band 1] [...] 1946-1963, Nr. 2708/13.
  5. Beers, F. W., & Redd, J. T. (1877). Map of Richmond, Manchester and suburbs [Map].
  6. https://lva.primo.exlibrisgroup.com/permalink/01LVA_INST/altrmk/alma990017362930205756.
  7. Auszug aus der Niederschrift. (1959). Auszug aus der Niederschrift über die Dienstbesprechung mit den Leitern der Bezirksrechtsämter am 16. 11. 1959 - Nr. 72/59, "Schutz der öffentlichen Grünanlagen - Az.: 660.10-5". Staatsarchiv Hamburg, 131-1 11_2708 Öffentliche Grünanlagen - Erhaltung, Ausbau und Pflege [Band 1] [...] 1946-1963.
  8. Auszug aus der Niederschrift. (1961). Auszug aus der Niederschrift über die Dienstbesprechung mit den Leitern der Bezirksrechtsämter am 20. 3. 1961 - Nr. 17/61, "Verstärkter Schutz der Grünanlagen - Az.: 660.10-5 (65.20-2)". Staatsarchiv Hamburg, 131-1 11_2708 Öffentliche Grünan-lagen - Erhaltung, Ausbau und Pflege [Band 1] [...] 1946-1963.
  9. Blight, D. W. (2002). Race and Reunion: The Civil War in American Memory. Harvard University Press.
  10. Board of Aldermen: Public Works, (1874, October 27). Richmond Daily Whig, p. 3, c. 2.
  11. Brouwer, P., & Verlaan, T. (2013). Symbolic gestures? Planning and replanning Amsterdam’s Bijlmermeer and new town Almere since 1965. Informationen Zur Modernen Stadtgeschichte, 1, 48–59.
  12. Büch. (1953a). Senator Büch, Drucksache für die Senatssitzung Nr. 982, „Mitteilung des Senats an den Bürgerausschuss", 23.09.1953. Staatsar-chiv Hamburg, 131-1 11_2708 Öffentliche Grünanlagen - Erhaltung, Ausbau und Pflege [Band 1] [...] 1946-1963, Nr. 2708/45-46.
  13. Büch. (1953b). Senator Büch, Drucksache für die Senatssitzung Nr. 286, „Mitteilung des Senats an den Bürgerausschuss", 26.03.1953. Staatsar-chiv Hamburg, 131-1 11_2708 Öffentliche Grünanlagen - Erhaltung, Ausbau und Pflege [Band 1] [...] 1946-1963, Nr. 2708/26-27.
  14. Bucerius. (1946). Senator Dr. Bucerius an die Senatskanzlei, Hamburg/Rathaus, "Erhaltung der öffentlichen Parks, Grün- und Freiflächen," 7.6.1946. Staatsarchiv Hamburg, 131-1 11_2708 Öffentliche Grünanlagen - Erhaltung, Ausbau und Pflege [Band 1] [...] 1946-1963, Nr. 2708/1-2.
  15. Cardon, N. (2018). A Dream of the Future: Race, Empire, and Modernity at the Atlanta and Nashville World’s Fairs. Oxford University Press.
  16. Chapman, E., Bukovski, V., Van Lierop, M., Tomasi, S., & Pauleit, S. (2024). Towards More Equitable Urban Greening: A Framework for Monitor-ing and Evaluating Co-Governance. Urban Planning, 9, 8184. https://doi.org/10.17645/up.8184
  17. Chesson, M.B. (1981) Richmond After the War, 1865-1900, Virginia State Library.
  18. Chimborazo as a Public Park. (1874, July 16). The Daily Dispatch, p. 1, c. 3.
  19. Chimborazo Park. (1871, September 2). The Daily Dispatch, p. 1, c. 5.
  20. Chimborazo Park. (1874a, September 4). The Daily Dispatch, p. 2, c. 4.
  21. Chimborazo Park. (1874b, November 16). The Daily Dispatch p. 2, c. 1.
  22. Chimborazo – What It Is and What It Might Be Made. (1871, April 25). The Daily Dispatch, p. 1, c. 5.
  23. Citizens of Richmond (presumed). (ca. 1871). [Petition to the Hon. City Council of Richmond]. Library of Virginia Archives & Special Collections, (City Administration Records, 1782-1979, Box Richmond City Council Papers: 1874-1884, Folder 1875-1880 (1045444)), Richmond, VA, Unit-ed States.
  24. cl. (1956, May 28). Liegewiesen wurden mißhandelt. Freigabe von Rasenflächen in diesem Jahr nach neuem Plan. Die Welt.
  25. Claypole, J. (2009). Tune in, Drop out. Frieze, 4 (122).
  26. Clark, P. (Ed.). (2006). The European City and Green Space: London, Stockholm, Helsinki and St. Petersburg, 1850 - 2000. Ashgate.
  27. Cranz, G. (1982). The Politics of Park Design: a History of Urban Parks in America. MIT Press.
  28. Cranz, G. (1980). Women in Urban Parks. Signs, 5(3), S79–S95. http://www.jstor.org/stable/3173808
  29. Cranz, G., & Boland, M. (2004). Defining the Sustainable Park. Landscape Journal, 23(2), 102–120. https://doi.org/10.3368/lj.23.2.102
  30. Crompton, J. L. (2014). Lessons from nineteenth-century advocacy in the USA for urban parks as antidotes for ill health. World Leisure Journal, 56(4), 267–280. https://doi.org/10.1080/16078055.2014.939504
  31. Crompton J. L. (2013). The Health Rationale for Urban Parks in the Nineteenth Century in the USA. World Leisure Journal 55(4), 333-346. https://doi.org/10.1080/04419057.2013.836557
  32. de Miguel Gonzalez, R. (2019). Europe in a Global Context: Eurogeo and the Role of Geography and European Geographers. European Journal of Geography, 10(4), 160-176. https://eurogeojournal.eu/index.php/egj/article/view/209
  33. Deutsche Bundesbank. (2024, January 19). Kaufkraftäquivalente historischer Beträge in deutschen Währungen. https://www.bundesbank.de/resource/blob/622372/d64726452d1eb2f62ce667f6784f89bb/mL/kaufkraftaequivalente-historischer-betraege-in-deutschen-waehrungen-data.pdf
  34. Dovey, K., Ristic, M., & Pafka, E. (2018). Mapping as Spatial Knowledge. In K. Dovey, M. Ristic, & E. Pafka (Eds.), Mapping Urbanities. Morpholo-gies, Flows, Possibilities (pp.1–16). Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group.
  35. Downs, G. P. (2015). After Appomattox: Military Occupation and the Ends of War. Harvard University Press.
  36. Enss, C. M., & Knauer, B. (Eds.). (2022). Atlas Kriegsschadenskarten Deutschland: Stadtkartierung und Heritage Making im Wiederaufbau um 1945. De Gruyter.
  37. Erensü, S., & Karaman, O. (2017). The Work of a Few Trees: Gezi, Politics and Space. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 41(1), 19–36. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-2427.12387
  38. Fisenne. (1955). Senator, An das Ortsamt Blankenese- Gartenbauabteilung Baubehörde, Hamburg, "Fachliche Weisung G Nr. 1/55, Betr.: Frei-gabe von Rasenflächen", 13.07.1955. Staatsarchiv Hamburg, 131-1 11_2708 Öffentliche Grünanlagen - Erhaltung, Ausbau und Pflege [Band 1] [...] 1946-1963.
  39. Foerster. (1953). Dr. h.c. Karl Foerster, dem Hohen Senat der Freien u. Hansestadt Hamburg, 04.08.1953. Staatsarchiv Hamburg, 131-1 11_2708 Öffentliche Grünanlagen - Erhaltung, Ausbau und Pflege [Band 1] [...] 1946-1963, Nr. 2708/34.
  40. Foner, E. (1989). Reconstruction: America’s Unfinished Revolution, 1863-1877 (1st Perennial Library ed.). Harper & Row.
  41. Freie und Hansestadt Hamburg. Behörde für Stadtentwicklung und Umwelt. (Ed.). (2014). Hamburgs Grün zwischen Tradition und Trends.
  42. Gallo, S. (2021). A Central Park of Their Own: Public Parks and the New South Movement, 1865-1920. ProQuest Dissertations & Theses.
  43. Green, C. C. (2004). Chimborazo: The Confederacy’s Largest Hospital (1st ed.). University of Tennessee Press.
  44. Gregory, I., & Ell, P. S. (2007). Historical GIS: Technologies, methodologies, and scholarship. Cambridge University Press.
  45. hamburg.de. (2024). Öffentliche Grünanlagen. Behörde für Umwelt, Klima, Energie und Agrarwirtschaft. https://www.hamburg.de/politik-und-verwaltung/behoerden/bukea/themen/klimaschutz/klimaanpassung/oeffentliche-gruenanlagen-254600
  46. Hamburg – Blankenese. (1953). Hamburg - Blankenese, An – O B - "Betr.: Bericht der Staatl. Pressestelle über die Aufbauarbeit Hamburgs in der Zeit von 1949 –1953," 14.09.1953. Staatsarchiv Hamburg, 445-1_1398.
  47. Hamburger Garten- und Friedhofsamt. (ca. 1972). Staatsarchiv Hamburg, 327-1_265, Nr. 114-115.
  48. Harvey, D. (1990). The Condition of Postmodernity. An Enquiry into the Origins of Cultural Change. Blackwell Publishers.
  49. Hillyer, R. (2015). Designing Dixie Tourism, Memory, and Urban Space in the New South (1st ed.). University of Virginia Press.
  50. Irani, M. (2022). Experiences, Characteristics, and Features of Developing New Towns between 1898 and 1970. European Journal of Geography, 13(5), 75–96. https://doi.org/10.48088/ejg.m.ira.13.5.75.96
  51. Jacobs, J. (1992). The Death and Life of Great American cities (Vintage Books ed). Vintage Books.
  52. Jess, H. (1952). Henning Jess (Ltd. Regierungsdirektor), an Senatssyndikus Harder, "Schutz der öffentlichen Anlagen," 04.02.1952. Staatsarchiv Hamburg, 131-1 11_2708 Öffentliche Grünanlagen - Erhaltung, Ausbau und Pflege [Band 1] [...] 1946-1963, Nr. 2708/16.
  53. Jung, I. (2013, May 13) Die Eroberung des Alsterufers, Hamburger Abendblatt, p. 6.
  54. Kemp, K. K. (2009). What can GIS offer history? International Journal of Humanities and Arts Computing, 3 (1–2),15–19. https://doi.org/10.3366/ijhac.2009.0006
  55. Kramper, P. (2008). Neue Heimat: Unternehmenspolitik und Unternehmensentwicklung im gewerkschaftlichen Wohnungs- und Städtebau 1950-1982. Steiner.
  56. Le Corbusier. (1973). The Athens Charter (A. Eardley, Trans.). Grossmann Publishers.
  57. Lefebvre, H. (1991). The production of space (D. Nicholson-Smith, Trans.). Blackwell Publishing.
  58. Lepik, A., Strobl, H. (Eds.). (2020). Die Neue Heimat (1950-1982): Eine sozialdemokratische Utopie und ihre Bauten (2nd ed.). Edition DETAIL.
  59. Lodders, R. (1947). Architekt Rudolf Lodders Hamburg-Altona: „4. Grünflächen (Auszug aus dem Referat vor dem Senat am 24. März 1947)." Staatsarchiv Hamburg, 131-1 11_2708 Öffentliche Grünanlagen - Erhaltung, Ausbau und Pflege [Band 1] [...] 1946-1963, Nr. 2708/7.
  60. Lorton, M.A. (presumed). (1869, January 20). [Petition to Maj. Genl. George E. Stoneman]. Library of Virginia Archives & Special Collections (City Administration Records, 1782-1979, Miscellaneous Series Richmond City Council Papers, 1865-1870, Box Council Papers 1869 – 1870), Rich-mond, VA, United States.
  61. Lüth, E. (ca. 1949). Drei Jahre Arbeit für den Wiederaufbau der Freien und Hansestadt Hamburg. Hans Christians Druckerei und Verlag.
  62. Massey, D. B. (1994). Space, Place, and Gender. University of Minnesota Press.
  63. McKittrick, K. (2006). Demonic Grounds: Black Women and the Cartographies of Struggle (NED-New edition). University of Minnesota Press.
  64. Morgan, C. S. (1849). Plan of Richmond (Henrico County), Manchester & Springhill, Virginia [Map]. [publisher not identified]. https://lva.primo.exlibrisgroup.com/permalink/01LVA_INST/altrmk/alma990016020620205756
  65. …Motions, Resolutions, and Orders. (1874, July 14). The Daily Dispatch, p. 1, c. 3-4.
  66. Noll, S., & Bhar, T. (2023). The Five Pillars of Urban Environmental Justice: A Framework for Building Equitable Cities. Philosophy of the City Jour-nal, 1(1), 84–99. https://doi.org/10.21827/potcj.1.1.41048.
  67. OECD. (2018). Green area per capita (square meters per capita). https://data.humdata.org/dataset/green-area-per-capita-square-meters-per-capita?force_layout=desktop
  68. On the Chimborazo. (1896, August 22). Richmond Planet, p. 1, c. 7.
  69. Park, S.-Y. (2018). Ideals of the Body: Architecture, Urbanism, and Hygiene in Postrevolutionary Paris. University of Pittsburgh Press.
  70. Picon, A. (2024). Natures Urbaines. Une Histoire Technique et Sociale, 1600-2023. Pavillon de l’Arsenal.
  71. Potterfield, T. T. (2009). Nonesuch Place: A History of the Richmond Landscape. History Press.
  72. Public Parks. (1872, July 30). Daily State Journal. p. 1, c. 3.
  73. Rabinowitz, H. N. (1980). Race Relations in The Urban South, 1865-1890. University of Illinois Press.
  74. Randolph, L. A. (2003). Rights For a Season: The Politics of Race, Class, and Gender in Richmond, Virginia (1st ed.). University of Tennessee Press.
  75. ra. (1956, August 29). Fortschritte am Alsterpark. Tauziehen um Quadratmeter – Bürgerschaft muß enteignen. Die Welt.
  76. Richmond Common Council. (1877, April 16). Records of Common Council (20), 1874 July-1878 June, Richmond (VA) City Administration Records, 1782-1979. Library of Virginia Archives & Special Collections, Richmond, VA, United States.
  77. Roe, J., & McCay, L. (2021). Restorative Cities: Urban Design for Mental Health and Wellbeing. Bloomsbury Visual Arts.
  78. Rosen, H. (Hannah R.). (2009). Terror in the Heart of Freedom: Citizenship, Sexual violence, and the Meaning of Race in the Postemancipation South. University of North Carolina Press.
  79. Rosenzweig, R., & Blackmar, E. (1992). The Park and the People: A History of Central Park. Cornell University Press.
  80. Rothstein, R. (2017). The Color of Law: a Forgotten History of How Our Government Segregated America (First edition.). Liveright Publishing Corporation.
  81. Rücke, K. H. (1959, March, 2). Stille Winkel im Grünen werden knapp. Forderungen des Landschaftsausschusses. Es geht um die Gesundheit der Bürger. Die Welt.
  82. Silver, C. (1984). Twentieth-Century Richmond: Planning, Politics, and Race. University of Tennessee Press.
  83. Steinhäuser, F. (Ed.). (2019). Die Neue Heimat. Eine sozialdemokratische Utopie und ihre Bauten. Landeszentrale für politische Bildung Hamburg.
  84. Struve. (1953). Regierungsdirektor Dr. Struve an die Baubehörde Hamburg, "Ersuchen des Bürgerausschusses an den Senat um Auskunft über Grünflächen,", 15.08.1953. Staatsarchiv Hamburg, 131-1 11_2708 Öffentliche Grünanlagen - Erhaltung, Ausbau und Pflege [Band 1] [...] 1946-1963, Nr. 2708/40-42.
  85. de Swaan, A. (1988). In Care of the State. Health Care, Education and Welfare in Europe and the USA in the Modern Era. Cambridge University Press.
  86. Szczygiel, B., & Hewitt, R. (2000). Nineteenth-Century Medical Landscapes: John H. Rauch, Frederick Law Olmsted, and the Search for Salubrity. Bulletin of the History of Medicine, 74(4), 708–734. http://www.jstor.org/stable/44444779
  87. Tarter, B. (2020). Virginians and Their Histories. University of Virginia Press.
  88. Tisma, S., Boromisa, A.-M., Farkaš, A., & Tolić, I. (2022). Socio-economic Evaluations of Nature Protected Areas: Health First Effect. European Journal of Geography, 11(1). https://eurogeojournal.eu/index.php/egj/article/view/124.
  89. Tuan, Y. (2002). Space and Place: The Perspective of Experience. University of Minnesota press.
  90. Virginia Business Directory and Gazetteer and Richmond City Directory. (1877). J.W. Randolph & English.
  91. Virginia Business Directory and Gazetteer and Richmond City Directory. (1879). J.W. Randolph & English.
  92. Voldman, D. (2023). Fabriquer la ville: Entre contraintes et innovations, France, XXe siècle. Atlande.
  93. Waitt, G., & Knobel, H. (2018). Embodied geographies of liveability and urban parks. Urban Studies, 55(14), 3151–3167. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042098017740080
  94. Wheatley, D., & Gillings, M. (2005). Spatial technology and archaeology: The archeaological applications of GIS. Taylor & Francis.
  95. Winichakul, T. (1994). Siam Mapped: A History of the Geo-Body of a Nation. University of Hawaii Press.
  96. Yates, A. (2019). Home-Making: Returnees, Squatters, and Planners in Postwar France. Journal of Urban History, 45(5), 1084–1088. https://doi.org/10.1177/0096144218769882
  97. Zimmer, A., Cornea, N., & Véron, R. (2016). Of parks and politics: The production of socio-nature in a Gujarati town. Local Environment, 22(1), 49–66. https://doi.org/10.1080/13549839.2016.1157157